People often refer to stereo when talking about sound and music, but not so often about sight. Stereopsis is the enhancement of sight by using two eyes. Having two eyes allows one to have depth perception that would not be possible with just one eye. Looking at the college years and twenties through the lens of Souls in Transition and The Defining Decade helps us see emerging adulthood much more clearly. Though the two works focus on the same subject, they are positioned from different angles which make stereopsis possible.
Souls in Transition comes from a sociologist focusing on religion and early emerging adulthood, while The Defining Decade is from a psychologist looking at the twenties in general. Souls in Transition is an academic work, The Defining Decade a self-help and motivational book. But don’t be deceived, they both help us see emerging adulthood in sharper contrast.
If emerging adulthood were surfing on a bright sunny day off Oahu, then Souls in Transition would be bringing those relentless waves into focus. Are the waves cresting? How long is the tube? Is the wind blowing offshore or onshore? We just don’t see the individual surfer, but also the forces that propel that surfer. Souls does offer some case studies that highlight individuals much as The Defining Decade does, but the real punch of Souls comes from its tables and charts. We see the ocean.
Souls in Transition is the second in a series by Christian Smith who analyzed and interpreted the National Study of Youth and Religion which interviewed 13-17 year olds. He released his first book, Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers in 2005. Souls in Transition looks at third wave data he has gleaned more recently and specifically looks young adults from 18 to 23 years old, which meshes well with the traditional college demographic. Dr. Smith wants to ask questions and these are the questions he asks: “What do the religious and spiritual lives of American 18-23-year olds look like and why? What are the social influences that shape people’s lives during these years? And how do people change or not change religiously and spiritually as they exit their teenage years and head into their twenties?”
Some of the answers we get are surprising:
*The religious lives of parents are one of the most powerful influences on the outcome of emerging adults.
*Teenagers are still more influenced by parents or other caring adults than peers
*There is little evidence for internal belief without external expression
*Attending college does not increase the chance of losing one’s faith
*Most emerging adults think nobody ultimately really knows what is true, right, or good
*Emerging adults as “sovereign individuals” lack conviction or direction
For all those pastors who have been saying the ultimate responsibility for a child’s religious education rests on the parents they are right. But even if a parent cannot be there, some other adult’s involvement in the life of teenager is highly important for the religious outcome in the emerging adult years. Teenagers and emerging adults need older adults as mentors and guides.
Perhaps some of the most perceptive writing about this observation comes in the section entitled The Cultural Triumph of Liberal Protestantism. Here referring to the work of sociologist N. Jay Demerath, Smith relates how the decline of liberal Protestantism is actually a victory of their theology, since more and more emerging adults have no reason to care about religion. Smith writes: “liberal Protestantism’s core values—individualism, pluralism, emancipation, tolerance, free critical inquiry, and the authority of human experience—have come to so permeate broader American culture that its own churches as organizations have difficulty surviving.” Even though liberal Protestantism has all but imploded, it has won the theology wars by leaving a “who cares about religion” mindset with most emerging adults.
Though we have only skimmed the waves in this review, Souls is a profound book that every leader working with emerging adults should read. Its scope and magnitude go far beyond “college students” to seeing how waves are developed well out to sea. Staff working with youth and parents would be wise to read it as well. Coming in at over 300 pages, however, it is not the type of book most emerging adults will actually read. What is where The Defining Decade come in.
If Souls helps us see with more clarity the waves pushing our imaginary suffer, then The Defining Decade by Dr. Meg Jay, focuses on the surfer, and the decisions he or she makes. Is she turning left or right? Is she about to wipeout? What board is he riding? Looking through the lens of The Defining Decade we see the twists and turns the surfer should make, hold our breaths as they shoot through the pipeline, and rejoice with them as they ride the really big ones.
Though not written from a religious perspective like Souls, there are echoes of the wisdom literature in this book. Whether describing work, love, or the brain and the body, there is a much needed common sense attitude that comes through to the reader. We can resonate with her advice saying, “The church has been saying this for years!”
The main theme of Dr. Jay, is that the surfer actually has to surf, and the earlier the better. After college, many emerging adults tend to just drift on their boards without actually standing up. Dr. Jay wants to change that by lending her experience in counseling to any and all twentysomthings who will listen and realize that their twenties do in fact matter.
Dr. Jay reminds emerging adults about key guides for life:
*Identity capital is important and needs to be cultivated early.
*That prudent life choices in one’s twenties sets the stage for success in later life
*That too many choices can lead to paralysis
*That who you marry is one of the most important decisions in life, and no one in college teaches you how to decide.
*How commonalities and similar likes help sustain a marriage
*That couples who live together actually have more of chance of divorce after marriage.
Those in collegiate ministry can use these books to help them zoom in or pan out to see the particular student or wave as needed. Souls in Transition can be used to help build an integrated ministry from teenager to early emerging adult. The Declining Decade makes a good book for an individual emerging adult to read by herself, and to help parents, grand-parents, and lay leaders understand the zeitgeist of mellinnenials.
Putting these two books together helps us see a way forward for ministry with emerging adults:
*Churches need to be coaching parents on how to mentor their children in religious development
*Transmission by participation needs to replace transmission by entertainment
*Mentoring needs to begin early and continue through early emerging adulthood
*Evangelism must be done beyond the church walls since most emerging adults aren’t interested in coming to a church service
*Ministries can reach emerging adults in their brokenness and indecision through incarnational ministry that is passionate, directional, and healing
These two books work well together helping to balance the tendency by some who think a self-help book can solve any problem, or those who think everything is determined by sociological factors. As Christians we know that God has given us personal choice and a mandate to follow him, yet readily admit that God remains sovereign. In reading these two books, we are reminded of this tension of sovereignty and choice: of the crash of the wave, and the use of a board. Let’s do our part in reading these books to be the best surfing coaches, lifeguards, oceanographers, and weather forecasters we can.